execsvc: a new error shape, 473× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no )
critical
Error never seen before
production
resolved
impact 72
Owner: Madhava Mukkamala (backup: Shashank Agrawal)
opened 1d ago · last observed 1d ago · observed 3× · #17464 · 9ecfe37306b2842f00c3
What happened template
execsvc logged “failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=? activityRefId=?” 473 times in the last hour and never before in 90 days on production (first seen 2026-11-16 16:26 UTC, raised at execution/activityV2.go:882). Example trace: b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c.
An error shape appearing for the first time in 90 days, five or more times in an hour.
First look — investigated before anyone looked
Cause not clear from logs and recent changes; execsvc logged 203 'failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation' errors at execution/activityV2.go:882 between 16:26 and 16:31 UTC on 2026-11-16, a shape never seen in 90 days.
The inner error 'no result from branch evaluation' (execlib/branchV2.go:77, 203×) has existed since 2026-11-11. The wrapping auto-query path is new from 16:26, along with 23× 'evalResult is not a bool' (branchV2.go:82).
The only execsvc deploy was a config revision 6db9855a7d34 by [email protected] at 05:10 UTC, 676 min before onset. Nothing links it to these errors.
Code and commits could not be read because the GitHub call budget ran out.
Next step: open the example trace and check whether all failures share one protocolId (e.g. 77bcfccb-…), which would point to a newly published protocol's branch/auto-query rule rather than a code change.
low confidence
claude-opus-5-5 · 1d ago · $0.04 — every link above is evidence it read; nothing else was claimed.
The facts
| service | execsvc |
| caller | execution/activityV2.go:882 |
| shape | failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=? activityRefId=? |
| count | 473 |
| error_class | — |
| first_seen | 2026-11-16 16:26:25 UTC (1d ago) |
| sample | failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=77bcfccb-cc59-4aea-bff8-0991eaa0c788 activityRefId=d3ad124c-6a7b-419c-b01d-522c2c83e633 |
| trace | b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c |
| shape_hash | b2fe02648cda5031 |
| count_is_floor | no |
| discriminator | b2fe02648cda5031 |
| window | 2026-11-16 16:18:03 UTC → 2026-11-16 17:18:03 UTC |
What is failing in execsvc — the bad events, decomposed
“Bad events” are HTTP 5xx answers from execsvc. In this finding's window (2026-11-16 16:18:03 UTC → 2026-11-16 17:18:03 UTC) there were 0; every line links to the grouped errors behind it.
The error shapes behind them
| 7× | error anchor visit index has not been set. Does this study have an anchor visit? continuing without setting day/date ran… since 2026-11-12 15:42:02 UTC |
| 6× | could not list DutyPlans for Study 85333258-21d0-4c47-92b2-da3a9fa8428f: passed Study was not found since 2026-10-12 17:57:06 UTC |
The story — No execsvc deploy or hand change is recorded in the hour before this opened. Everything below is execsvc only.
- 2026-11-16 15:32:01 UTCcypher execsvc shape 44491433 p95 went 18 ms → 62 ms across the window (272 runs)
- 2026-11-16 16:32:01 UTCfinding · critical execsvc: a new error shape, 75× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — eva)
- 2026-11-16 16:32:01 UTCfinding · critical execsvc: a new error shape, 75× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (evalResult is not a bool)
- 2026-11-16 16:32:01 UTCthis finding execsvc: a new error shape, 473× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no )
- 2026-11-16 17:00:00 UTClatency execsvc p95 peaked at 1.83 s
History
- 2026-11-16 16:32:01 UTCopened x-ray · severity=critical title=execsvc: a new error shape, 203× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no ) finding={'id': 17464, 'fingerprint': '9ecfe37306b2842f00c3', 'kind': 'error.novel', 'severity': 'critical', 'cluster': 'production', 'subject': 'execsvc', 'title': 'execsvc: a new error shape, 203× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no )', 'facts': {'service': 'execsvc', 'caller': 'execution/activityV2.go:882', 'shape': 'failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=? activityRefId=?', 'count': 203, 'error_class': None, 'first_seen': 1794846385, 'sample': 'failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=77bcfccb-cc59-4aea-bff8-0991eaa0c788 activityRefId=d3ad124c-6a7b-419c-b01d-522c2c83e633', 'trace': 'b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c', 'shape_hash': 'b2fe02648cda5031', 'window': [1794843121, 1794846721], 'count_is_floor': False, 'discriminator': 'b2fe02648cda5031'}, 'evidence': [{'label': 'Errors, grouped', 'href': '/errors?cluster=production&from=1794843121&to=1794846721&service=execsvc'}, {'label': 'Logs', 'href': '/logs?cluster=production&from=1794843121&to=1794846721&service=execsvc&severity=ERROR'}, {'label': 'Example trace', 'href': '/trace/b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c?cluster=production'}], 'provenance': {'source': 'live', 'collected_at': None, 'age_seconds': None, 'stale': False, 'shown': None, 'total': None, 'truncated': False, 'coverage_from': None, 'retain_days': None, 'note': 'Cloud Logging, last hour, grouped by (service, caller, shape)'}, 'impact': 71.1, 'status': 'open', 'first_seen': 1794846721, 'last_seen': 1794846721, 'resolved_at': None, 'acked_by': None, 'acked_at': None, 'snoozed_until': None, 'occurrences': 1, 'narrative': None, 'narrative_kind': None, 'discriminator': 'b2fe02648cda5031', 'level': 'high', 'told_level': None, 'episode_at': 1794846721, 'chat_thread': None, 'kind_label': 'Error never seen before', 'group': 'Errors', 'age_s': 31, 'stale_s': 31}
- 2026-11-16 17:28:30 UTCnotified x-ray · alert_id=10 channel=in-app status=delivered send_id=51845
- 2026-11-16 17:28:30 UTCnotified x-ray · alert_id=10 channel=prod-notifications status=sent send_id=51845
- 2026-11-16 17:34:53 UTCresolved x-ray · reason=not observed grace_s=900 finding={'id': 17464, 'fingerprint': '9ecfe37306b2842f00c3', 'kind': 'error.novel', 'severity': 'critical', 'cluster': 'production', 'subject': 'execsvc', 'title': 'execsvc: a new error shape, 473× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no )', 'facts': {'service': 'execsvc', 'caller': 'execution/activityV2.go:882', 'shape': 'failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=? activityRefId=?', 'count': 473, 'error_class': None, 'first_seen': 1794846385, 'sample': 'failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=77bcfccb-cc59-4aea-bff8-0991eaa0c788 activityRefId=d3ad124c-6a7b-419c-b01d-522c2c83e633', 'trace': 'b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c', 'shape_hash': 'b2fe02648cda5031', 'window': [1794845883, 1794849483], 'count_is_floor': False, 'discriminator': 'b2fe02648cda5031'}, 'evidence': [{'label': 'Errors, grouped', 'href': '/errors?cluster=production&from=1794845883&to=1794849483&service=execsvc'}, {'label': 'Logs', 'href': '/logs?cluster=production&from=1794845883&to=1794849483&service=execsvc&severity=ERROR'}, {'label': 'Example trace', 'href': '/trace/b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c?cluster=production'}], 'provenance': {'source': 'live', 'collected_at': None, 'age_seconds': None, 'stale': False, 'shown': None, 'total': None, 'truncated': False, 'coverage_from': None, 'retain_days': None, 'note': 'Cloud Logging, last hour, grouped by (service, caller, shape)'}, 'impact': 72.5, 'status': 'resolved', 'first_seen': 1794846721, 'last_seen': 1794849483, 'resolved_at': 1794850493, 'acked_by': None, 'acked_at': None, 'snoozed_until': None, 'occurrences': 3, 'narrative': 'execsvc logged “failed to evaluate and raise auto query for participant question — no result from branch evaluation for branch, protocolId=? activityRefId=?” 473 times in the last hour and never before in 90 days on production (first seen 2026-11-16 16:26 UTC, raised at execution/activityV2.go:882). Example trace: b4a46af1511b00609ba4b32b4050ff0c.', 'narrative_kind': 'template', 'discriminator': 'b2fe02648cda5031', 'level': 'high', 'told_level': 'high', 'episode_at': 1794846721, 'chat_thread': 'xray-alert-10-748fd5a928-g-1794850110', 'kind_label': 'Error never seen before', 'group': 'Errors', 'age_s': 3803, 'stale_s': 1041}
- 2026-11-16 21:29:12 UTCnotified x-ray · alert_id=10 channel=in-app status=delivered send_id=51911
- 2026-11-16 21:29:12 UTCnotified x-ray · alert_id=10 channel=prod-notifications status=sent send_id=51911
Notifications
- 2026-11-16 21:29:12 UTCresolvedin-app · delivered
- 2026-11-16 21:29:12 UTCresolvedprod-notifications · sent
Check it yourself
Every link carries the finding's own time window, so it shows tomorrow what it shows now.
Actions
Sign in (IAP) to acknowledge, snooze or resolve.
Where the numbers come from
| source | live |
| collected_at | None |
| age_seconds | None |
| stale | False |
| shown | None |
| total | None |
| truncated | False |
| coverage_from | None |
| retain_days | None |
| note | Cloud Logging, last hour, grouped by (service, caller, shape) |
| detector | errors_novel |