execsvc: a new error shape, 9× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2)
critical
Error never seen before
delta
open
impact 69
Owner: Madhava Mukkamala (backup: Shashank Agrawal)
opened 1d ago · last observed 23h ago · observed 3× · #17516 · bca64aa3164a6c0078e8
What happened template
execsvc logged “Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2” 9 times in the last hour and never before in 90 days on delta (first seen 2026-11-17 09:46 UTC, raised at observability/middleware.go:281). Example trace: 9bff744b81af07042b1e3e7de4963df4.
An error shape appearing for the first time in 90 days, five or more times in an hour.
First look — investigated before anyone looked
Cause not clear from logs and recent changes; execsvc returned 500 "could not save Careplan activity V2" 9× between 09:46 and 09:54 UTC on 2026-11-17 (new shape, logged at observability/middleware.go:281).
Checked: no execsvc deploys in the 24 h before onset (running build deployed 2026-11-16 05:11 UTC by [email protected]), no other findings at the same time.
Alongside it: "no result from branch evaluation" (branchV2.go:77, 2×), "Question object not found for question" (questionV2.go:1863, 3×, new at 09:53), and pubsub "transaction was never committed" (2×).
The code shown (careplan.go:1044) is the 403 branch; the 500 comes from a later error path after execution.SaveActivityV2, whose underlying error is not in the bundle.
Next step: open the example trace to read the wrapped error from SaveActivityV2. Then check whether it matches the branch-evaluation or missing-question errors for that protocol.
low confidence
claude-opus-5-5 · 1d ago · $0.04 — every link above is evidence it read; nothing else was claimed.
The facts
| service | execsvc |
| caller | observability/middleware.go:281 |
| shape | Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2 |
| count | 9 |
| error_class | server_error |
| first_seen | 2026-11-17 09:46:15 UTC (1d ago) |
| sample | Request completed — 500 · could not save Careplan activity V2 |
| trace | 9bff744b81af07042b1e3e7de4963df4 |
| shape_hash | 6fe8657be3e9bf46 |
| count_is_floor | no |
| discriminator | 6fe8657be3e9bf46 |
| window | 2026-11-17 09:40:41 UTC → 2026-11-17 10:40:41 UTC |
The story — No execsvc deploy or hand change is recorded in the hour before this opened. Everything below is execsvc only.
- 2026-11-17 09:00:00 UTCerrors execsvc 5xx peaked at 10 in one five-minute bucket (median 0 in this window)
- 2026-11-17 09:00:00 UTClatency execsvc p95 peaked at 3.81 s
- 2026-11-17 09:59:37 UTCthis finding execsvc: a new error shape, 9× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2)
History
- 2026-11-17 09:59:37 UTCopened x-ray · severity=critical title=execsvc: a new error shape, 9× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2) finding={'id': 17516, 'fingerprint': 'bca64aa3164a6c0078e8', 'kind': 'error.novel', 'severity': 'critical', 'cluster': 'delta', 'subject': 'execsvc', 'title': 'execsvc: a new error shape, 9× in the last hour, never seen in 90 days (Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2)', 'facts': {'service': 'execsvc', 'caller': 'observability/middleware.go:281', 'shape': 'Request completed — ? · could not save Careplan activity V2', 'count': 9, 'error_class': 'server_error', 'first_seen': 1794908775, 'sample': 'Request completed — 500 · could not save Careplan activity V2', 'trace': '9bff744b81af07042b1e3e7de4963df4', 'shape_hash': '6fe8657be3e9bf46', 'window': [1794905977, 1794909577], 'count_is_floor': False, 'discriminator': '6fe8657be3e9bf46'}, 'evidence': [{'label': 'Errors, grouped', 'href': '/errors?cluster=delta&from=1794905977&to=1794909577&service=execsvc'}, {'label': 'Logs', 'href': '/logs?cluster=delta&from=1794905977&to=1794909577&service=execsvc&severity=ERROR'}, {'label': 'Example trace', 'href': '/trace/9bff744b81af07042b1e3e7de4963df4?cluster=delta'}], 'provenance': {'source': 'live', 'collected_at': None, 'age_seconds': None, 'stale': False, 'shown': None, 'total': None, 'truncated': False, 'coverage_from': None, 'retain_days': None, 'note': 'Cloud Logging, last hour, grouped by (service, caller, shape)'}, 'impact': 65.4, 'status': 'open', 'first_seen': 1794909577, 'last_seen': 1794909577, 'resolved_at': None, 'acked_by': None, 'acked_at': None, 'snoozed_until': None, 'occurrences': 1, 'narrative': None, 'narrative_kind': None, 'discriminator': '6fe8657be3e9bf46', 'level': 'medium', 'told_level': None, 'episode_at': 1794909577, 'chat_thread': None, 'kind_label': 'Error never seen before', 'group': 'Errors', 'age_s': 61, 'stale_s': 61}
Check it yourself
Every link carries the finding's own time window, so it shows tomorrow what it shows now.
Actions
Sign in (IAP) to acknowledge, snooze or resolve.
Where the numbers come from
| source | live |
| collected_at | None |
| age_seconds | None |
| stale | False |
| shown | None |
| total | None |
| truncated | False |
| coverage_from | None |
| retain_days | None |
| note | Cloud Logging, last hour, grouped by (service, caller, shape) |
| detector | errors_novel |